By: Scott Jentz
If you lead a credit union, there’s a set of dollars on your balance sheet that rarely comes up in a board meeting: the money your institution holds to fund its employee benefit obligations and executive retirement plans. That money matters a great deal to the future of a credit union, but at some institutions it is also the least explored.
It can end up in CDs and money markets, and when a term deposit matures, it may simply roll into the next one. Nobody decides to leave it there. It just stays.
I spent 28 years at a life insurance company before founding GSG, and I understand why this happens. Those dollars back the promises a credit union makes to its own employees and executives, and no CFO wants to get creative with a promise. But there’s a huge difference between safe and idle, and right now, the gap between them is getting wider.
Why Is This Happening Now?
For a few years, CDs and money markets looked pretty good. But that is starting to change. Rate cuts that began late last year have pulled yields down from their peak, and term deposits locked in at the top are maturing into a very different market.
That turns every maturity into a decision point. Roll it over at today’s rates, or ask whether those dollars could be doing more.
There’s good reason to ask. Since 2003, the NCUA has allowed federal credit unions to fund employee benefit obligations with investments that wouldn’t otherwise be permitted. Plenty of credit unions have never used that flexibility.
That flexibility applies when the investment funds an actual employee benefit obligation or a charitable donation account. State chartered credit unions should check their state’s rules.
Some credit unions grew through mergers and inherited a conservative investment approach without ever building a formal strategy. Others simply never had a reason to revisit it, until Acumen Financial Advantage entered the picture.
What Acumen’s Life Insurance Funds Are
Acumen Financial Advantage built its Life Insurance Funds for credit unions and mission-driven institutions specifically to help put benefit funding dollars to work.
In plain terms, they’re private funds backed by “A+” rated life insurance carriers. The funds are designed for dollars a credit union already holds to cover its benefit obligations, so no new capital is required.
The headline option is a five-year fund with a target 9% annual return. Income is paid quarterly. The funds are designed to return principal at maturity.
A few other things worth knowing:
- Backed by life insurance carriers. The structure is built around highly rated life insurance carriers rather than market-traded securities.
- Built for benefit funding. The funds are designed for employee benefit plan funding, including executive retirement obligations, and for charitable donation accounts.
- Limited added workload. Acumen handles implementation and ongoing oversight, but your board will still need to approve the investment and document it under your benefit plan policy.
What Sits Behind the Numbers
Understandably, a good CFO should be skeptical of a number like 9%. So here’s what sits behind it:
The funds are backed by A+ rated life insurance carriers. They’re audited, with ongoing performance monitoring. And they’re structured to align with NCUA guidelines for benefit plan funding and charitable donation accounts.
The evaluation starts with something you already have: your call report. Acumen uses it to model what the funds could look like at your institution before you commit to anything.
And in case you’re wondering, there are credit union partners of both GSG and CU*SOUTH that already work with Acumen, including FAA FCU.
The Same Question Applies to Executive Retention…
If the benefit funding conversation belongs to the CFO, this one belongs to the CEO and the board.
Executive benefit plans should align with tenure, not outlive it. Too many supplemental executive retirement plans (SERP) tie up capital for 30 years or more, long after the executive they were built for has moved on.
Acumen designs plans around actual tenure, which frees up capital for the next generation of leaders. Its broader range of SERP options can often reduce the capital needed to fund the same level of benefit by 25% or more.
If you already have a SERP in place, Acumen offers a complimentary audit. Depending on your situation, it can surface annual savings on the P&L, reduce exposure to the 21% excise tax on compensation over $1 million and ease scrutiny around Form 990 Schedule J for credit unions that file one.
For the executives in the plan, the same benefit may be delivered on a tax-advantaged basis instead of as a lump-sum taxable payment.
Where GSG Fits in
GSG is owned by credit unions, and we work closely with the institutions we serve. Part of our job is introducing our credit unions to solutions worth a look, even when the solution isn’t ours. Acumen’s Life Insurance Funds are one of those introductions. As with any investment, each credit union should complete its own due diligence.
Here’s how it works:
- You reach out to us.
- We coordinate with Acumen and set up the conversation.
- You get a complimentary call report analysis or SERP audit, with no obligation attached.
Request Your Complimentary Call Report Analysis or SERP Audit
Not ready for a conversation yet? Download Acumen’s executive retention fact sheet and look it over on your own time. I’m happy to answer any questions you may have.
Scott Jentz is founder, president and CEO of Gateway Services Group, a credit union-owned CUSO. He has spent more than four decades in financial services working with credit unions, including 28 years as Vice President of Group Sales at Minnesota Life Insurance Company. He founded GSG in 2000 to bring credit unions specialized insurance and investment solutions, and has since grown it into a nationwide partner for credit unions across the country.
Acumen’s Life Insurance Funds are offered by Acumen Financial Advantage. GSG works with credit unions to connect them with Acumen and coordinate consultations. The funds are not deposits, are not insured by NCUA or FDIC, are not guaranteed, may lose value, and are illiquid for the five year term; target returns are not guaranteed. Since Acumen offers the product, please have them provide or approve the final disclosure language.